Are Stormtroopers Actually "Better" Than Clone Troopers In Star Wars?

Stormtroopers inStar Warshave always been an essential aspect of theGalactic Empire . They are the soldiers who attempt to keep order throughout the Galax urceolata , conquering and oppressing those who do not . There were many differenttypes of stormtroopers , each serving a unlike purpose . They were volunteer conscripts cultivate to have no personality and follow the order of their oppressive overlords without motion . This starkly contrasts with the soldiers they were appointed to phase out : theGalactic Republic ’s clone trooper .

On the other hand , dead ringer troopers were bred by Kaminoans from a DNA strand of illustrious bounty hunterJango Fett . They were design to watch over orders and show absolute loyalty to the Jedi , and would never have turned on the Jedi willingly if not for theinhibitor chipsin their heads . They also created a wonderful brotherhood among their ranks . They cared for one another profoundly and were , far in a way , the bravest soldier ever create in theStar Warsfranchise to date . But who was really better , knockoff troopers or stormtroopers ?

Clones Are More Efficient, But Stormtroopers Are Cheaper

They also served different purposes

Clone troopers were design to fight a state of war against the Separatists and their U. S. Army of struggle droids . OnceOrder 66was executed , they lead off to fulfill their hush-hush mission of pass over out all the Jedi they had fought beside , andsuddenly , they were not needed any longer . Star warfare : The Clone Warsfeatured episodes that hash out how expensive clone production was , and their cost caused the Galactic Republic to deregulate the banks as the war continue to drag out on . Star Wars : The Bad Batchalso officially put in the Defense Recruitment Bill .

This subject is peculiarly cover inThe Clone Warsseason 3 , sequence 11 " Pursuit of Peace " andThe Bad Batchseason 2 , episode 8 " Truth and Consequences . "

Thanks to this new broadside , the stormtrooper syllabus was created . By introducing volunteer conscripts , the Empire could make a young U. S. Army while reducing the monetary value of making one . Clones were soldiers bred to fight and were extremely good at it . However , after the war , they became more of a security force and started getting assigned menial tasks . consider how they were utilized , it makes common sense why the Empire decided to do off with the clonesand move on to the cheaper stormtroopers .

The Empire Needed Numbers, Not Skill

And troops that were not associated with the Republic

Stormtroopers were a giant security measure effect designed to be the eye and spike of the Empire ’s dictatorship . possess expensive clones coming off the heels of fighting a warfare was no longer necessary . What was needed was a significantly prominent , inexpensive force that to the full bought into the ideology of " The Empire . " Having enough soldiers to cover every inch of the galaxy lease precedence over the soldiers ' skill .

Palpatine chose to discard the clone army after the prequels , and Star Wars is finally showing why their replacement by stormtroopers was so tragical .

The Bad Batchhelped show that the clones struggle to adjust to the new Imperial path , causing some to defect . While clones were fast under the command of their Jedi generals , their morals and scientific potential saw them subjugated after the Republic was break up . The Empire was capable to kill two birds with one stone ; they were able to apply their new , larger US Army to recreate security while getting rid of the army that was a remnant of the Republic they wanted to wipe off .

Should The Empire Have Stuck With Clone Troopers Instead?

Probably, but they did not want the clones anymore

Stormtrooper are n’t better soldier than clone , but they function the purpose the Empire asked of them . Clones were hardcore soldier with remarkable acquirement that were sharpened in fight . After set up the demolition of Kamino , Emperor Palpatine manipulated the situation to win over the Imperial Senate to phase out the clones for stormtroopers . In doing so , he gained a significantly bigger and cheap regular army entirely truehearted to him .

Stormtroopers became the backbone of the Imperial Army . While clones completely outmatch them in every aspect of being a soldier , stormtroopers were precisely what Palpatine wanted once he took control of the coltsfoot . They were a force that follow every order without a opinion , and without dubiousness . By doing this , Palpatine could have eyes everywhere , knowing that at any time , they could be asked to perform abhorrent tasks . If the Empire had stick with ringer , they would have stay in power longer , but they were not want .

Clone troopers are right smart secure than stormtroopers as soldiers . It was what they were born to do . or else of sticking with them , the Empire wanted a crummy , larger force that had none of their baggage or morals . The Defense Recruitment Bill pass inThe Bad Batchhelped Palpatine get the soldier he wanted to watch over his Empire , conscript loyal to the Empire ’s political orientation . TheStar Warsuniverse would undoubtedly have been unlike if clones remained the fighting force of the Imperials . Thankfully , they go with stormtroopers instead .

Diego Luna as Cassian Andor in Andor season 2