The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air
The argument ofJanet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian vs. Daphne Maxwell Reid ’s Aunt Vivianis one that has raged on for decades among sports fan of the dear sitcomThe Fresh Prince of Bel - Air . Though it would be hard to find many people who favor the second iteration of the iconic Aunt Viv , it can not be denied that both womanhood get their own unique talents and perspective to the grapheme .
It would be easy to argue that the first Aunt Vivian is a fundamentally different character than the 2nd Aunt Vivian . And it would also be well-fixed to quickly judge one as ranking to the other , simply because they were there first or they were there last . An argument is made in support of both of these women ’s interpretations .
Daphne Maxwell-Reid: Non-confrontational
While the first Aunt Vivian had a much unassailable and more confident disposition , the second Aunt Vivian comes across as a far more non - confrontational woman , especially when it comes to her marriage .
Even when Aunt Vivian and Uncle Phil get into an line of reasoning , Daphne Maxwell Reid ’s Aunt Vivian ’s go to move is to withdraw entirely from the situation rather than argue - which take totwo of the series ' most frustrating episode , when Phil and Vivian temporarily freestanding .
Janet Hubert: Queen of sass
Fresh Princefeatures mass ofbeloved and repeatable characters , but few of them sprain out reliable carrying out in the sass and sarcasm department quite the elbow room the first Aunt Vivian does .
Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian has a razor sharp wit , fit her telling mind and spitfire personality . She get ahead every argument she enters - and it ’s a real ignominy she was n’t the one who was around when Will ’s absentee father showed up .
Daphne Maxwell-Reid: Spends more time at home
It ’s debatable whether this is a honorable feature of Daphne Maxwell Reid ’s character , given the complete retconning of the previous edition of Aunt Vivian that it involves .
But Maxwell Reid ’s Aunt Vivian never seems to have a career , and as such , takes on the traditional role of wealthy homemaker . She ’s almost always featured in the series in scenes at house , which would conceivably allow for more interaction between Aunt Vivian and her family .
Janet Hubert: Multi-talented
Fresh Princedoesn’t shy away from exploring the biases and prejudices that existagainst woman once they extend to middle long time . But it also does n’t hesitate to allow Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian her moments to shine , even as she finger in short uncomfortable in her own skin .
One of the series ' most memorable episode finds Aunt Vivian exploring her preceding passion for dance , which leads to a really stunning video display of endowment from Janet Hubert in a saltation procedure for the sitcom record book .
Daphne Maxwell-Reid: Socialite chic
As part of the changes necessitate in moving from Janet Hubert to Daphne Maxwell Reid , Aunt Vivian no longer has a line of work , but expend her time socialize with fellow flush adult female of Bel - Air .
As such , her way pedigree receives a considerable hike , with many of her getup rival those of younger socialite and eventual talk of the town show host , her girl Hillary .
Janet Hubert: Successful career woman
From the showtime of the serial publication , it ’s clear that Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian is an incredibly empowered career woman . She influence as a university professor , and is fiercely protective of her students , particularly when they begin to stray .
She even temporarily serve as a substitute teacher specialise in dark story at Will and Carlton ’s private school , and quick becomes a ducky of the entire student body .
Daphne Maxwell-Reid: Her relationship with Nicky
Though it ’s Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian who is pregnant with little Nicky during the third season , Daphne Maxwell Reid ’s Aunt Vivian is the one who puzzle to call down him in the series ' final three seasons - both in his baby form , and in his rapidly aged toddler form .
While many of Aunt Vivian ’s moments with little Nicky take lieu in the background or blink and miss them scenes , the bond between mother and son proves an adorable plus to the serial ' later years .
Janet Hubert: Her relationship with Uncle Phil
When it comes todepictions of Black lovein modernistic situation comedy history , it ’d be difficult to obtain a more loving , more fiery , and more rude couple thanthe pairing of Uncle Phil and Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian .
The chemical science between these two never wavers , and the show never shy away from exploring their ruttish sides , as much as it was able to . No matter what , these two always came across as deeply in love with and attracted to one another .
Daphne Maxwell-Reid: Laid back
As already discussed above , Daphne Maxwell Reid ’s Aunt Vivian take a much more non - confrontational coming to her spousal relationship . But she also approach parenting in a much more laid back way , too .
With none of the first Aunt Vivian ’s fierce protective fire and flash , the second Aunt Vivian is much more lay back when it comes to parenting and penalize , leaving most of that responsibleness to Uncle Phil .
Janet Hubert: Tough, but loving
By contrast , the first Aunt Vivian is by far one of the best protective female parent characters in situation comedy history . She does n’t shy out from confronting her children , and her nephew , when they are in the wrong .
She calls them out for their failings , pushes them to do better , penalise them in baffling but just ways , and always , without fail , supports them whenever they need her to . Janet Hubert ’s Aunt Vivian was truly the mother all situation comedy children deserved .
NEXT : The Fresh Prince Of Bel - Air : 5 good ( & 5 Worst ) Episodes
