Summary
For 15 seasons , ERdefined what it meant to be a medical telecasting dramatic play , and though rebooting the beloved serial publication is a nice thought , anERreboot would have been the risky thing the serial publication could do . In a world full ofthe best medical dramas , ERis my absolute pet . Where other , more mod medical display verge on corny and highly unrealistic , ERalmost always maintains a sentiency of trueness . The medico at County General sure have their romances and dramas , but at the death of the day , their true focus is on helping the people of Chicago .
Another panorama ofERthat I lie with is that the show never became a franchise . After 15 time of year , the show never dig into spinoffs , sequels , or prequels . However , that almost changed in 2020 . While on theStill Here Hollywoodpodcast , ERalumNoah Wyle discussed his failedERrevival . He explain that after receiving an influx of heartwarming fanmail in 2020 , he hit out toERproducer John Wells and suggested a " much modest , and much more contained"show following one fibre in the present day . Ultimately , Wyle agreed thatit was a near thing the reboot never happen .
There ’s a lot to love about ER , one of the most popular medical drama of all time , including the best episode of each time of year .
Custom Image by Yailin Chacon
Noah Wyle’s ER Revival Idea Had Good Intentions, But Wouldn’t Have Worked
Too Much Nostalgia Would Ruin An ER Reboot
Although I appreciate Noah Wyle ’s aim , I ’m very glad hisERreboot never occur . Mainly , I feel the same mode that Wyle does . During his audience , the actor explained thattheERrevival ’s loser was a good thingbecause audience would have been overly concerned with the " brand"and " who ’s coming back . “Meanwhile , he was more concerned in the newfangled history that they could bring to the mesa . I finger the same way . As much as I would have a go at it anERreunion , the revival ’s integrity would be convey down if it seemed like mere fan service .
I trust that appearance fuel strictly on nostalgia rather than a impregnable level or characters are often doomed to be less than their source textile .
Furthermore , anERrevival would be nostalgic , and sometimes nostalgia hurts more than it helps . With too many references or cameos from the original series , the reboot might have felt like it was merely redoingER . It would n’t be able to win without the context of its predecessor . Plus , while I lovedthe ensemble cast ofER , it ’s a trick that I do n’t think can be restate , especially so many years later . In the end , I think that shows fire purely on nostalgia rather than a secure story or character are often doomed to be less than their seed material .
Why The 2020s ER Revival Never Happened
The Reboot Reached Development Purgatory
ground on Noah Wyle ’s podcast interview , it is n’t all well-defined why theERrevival did n’t happen , but we can posit a few theory . Wyle note that he teamed up with producer John Wells and an unnamedERwriter to get the reboot started . Though the trio came up with a concept , Wyle explain that " it really never got out of the start logic gate . " Then , on top of that , Wyle revealed that dialogue were a " non - starter . “In this way , I would guess that Wyle ’s visual sense did not agree what TV executives expectedfrom anERreboot .
consort toELLE , Noah Wyle and Laura Innes were two members ofER’soriginal cast who continue with the show for the longest sentence . They appeared in 13 out of 15 season .
As much as nostalgia can suffer a show , it ’s an emotion that Hollywood loves to pull on . Therefore , it seems likely that Wyle ’s miserable negotiations had to do with how much nostalgia theERrevival included . WhileWyle clearly wanted a freestanding chronicle with a singleERconnecting point , it ’s possible that the executives wanted more original cast to return and more nods to the 1994 series . This would compromise Wyle and Wells ' idea , make the show to go nowhere . disregarding of what it all means , I ’m just gladERremains untouched by sequels or spinoffs .
Why ER Should Never Be Brought Back
ER Told A Complete Story
It ’s tempting to seek and bring in back the good quondam days , but television serial likeERare impossible to remake . ER’sbest lineament simply can not be replaced today , including its mould , its topical storyline , and its time period . For me , one-half ofER’snostalgia amount from the 1990s context , which a revival could not organically remake . at last , Hollywood could put together an exciting cast and bang-up plot line , and it still would not be the same . It is better to simply rewatchERrather than endeavor to make lightning strike double .
Furthermore , ER’sstory came to a complete finish . Arguably , the showrunners squeezed every bite of narration they could out of it . In this way , it makes no good sense to go beyondER’s15 all-encompassing season . To me , the good thing to do withERis let it take a breather . There are so many medical dramas out in the worldly concern , andERis one of the best among them . In order of magnitude to keep its title , the show must merely stand on its own two legs without subsequence , prequels , spinoffs , or reboots .
